Jayasree ji, A brilliant monograph, well-argued and evidenced. Ananda Coomaraswamy provides a remarkable insight: ‘Myth embodies the nearest approach to absolute truth that can be stated in words. Narahari Achar, Srinivasa Raghavan and you have demonstrated a date of November 22, Nilkanth ji talks only about motion of Arundhati whose interpretation is doubtful and motion over long periods is inaccurate. Calculation only on basis of eclipses is also not proper as they are repeated after 18 years All our calendar calculations are from start of Kali on BC Ujjain midnight. Vakyakaran calculations and many dates of Kerala texts on jyotish are given on that basis. By trying to change many thousands of such calculations to show our wisdom, we are denying the whole knowledge structure of India.
Choose your reason below and click on the Report button. This will alert our moderators to take action. Nifty 11, YES Bank Market Watch. Politics and Nation.
The scientific dating of the Rāmāyaṇa & the Vedas Unknown Binding – January 1, by Padmākara Vishṇu Vartaka (Author).
While your assertion of Bhishma on the bed of arrows for 98…. This is how I tried to do it: The longitudes of A and V need to obtained in the globe with the magnetic poles as the new North and South poles. In a cartesian system with its x-axis along…. Koenraad Elst — When multiple findings from multiple disciplines are combined, they lead to robust understanding of the phenomenon nature, history, etc. Achar, he had reluctantly agreed that your observation of AV positions cannot be denied!
Srinivas Raghavan as the year of Mahbharata…. Compare this…. Had Yudhishthira not taken care of all these matters much earlier, immediately…. I am reproducing comments of Prof. Gupta since they are extremely relevant to the subject of ancient Indian history.
Ramayana Scientific Dating Wrong?
Padmakar Vishnu Vartak or P. Vartak 25 February — 29 March was a doctor by profession as well as a spiritualist, speaker, and author of several books that have been translated into many languages. The Vartak family had a generational business of making tapkir.
Scientific dating of the Ramayana proves Rama existed. Unlike the mythical doctrines of Christianity and Islam, Hindu religion has a basis in.
How far back in the past did the events described in the epics really take place? After a research stay at Benares Hindu University, he did original fieldwork for a doctorate on Hindu nationalism, which he obtained magna cum laude in He also published on the interface of religion and politics, correlative cosmologies, the dark side of Buddhism, the reinvention of Hinduism, technical points of Indian and Chinese philosophies, various language policy issues, Maoism, the renewed relevance of Confucius in conservatism, the increasing Asian stamp on integrating world civilization, direct democracy, the defence of threatened freedoms, and the Belgian question.
Regarding religion, he combines human sympathy with substantive skepticism. The dating of the Mahabharat and the Ramayan is a puzzle that refuses to yield a simple answer. Conferences after conferences have been held in India and abroad for historians to arrive at a consensus, which has remained elusive so far.
When was Ram born? Mahabharata war begin? Exhibition cracks it all
This article is from Open Magazine. The war he is referring to is the one that famously lasted for 18 days, the greatest of all wars. He switches on his laptop, clicks on Stellarium, a planetarium software that simulates the sky in 3D, feeds in some data, and soon we are staring at a configuration on the screen which looks like the night sky with stars glittering on it.
This is the sky just before the Battle of Kurukshetra, according to Bhatnagar, an astronomer who has spent the years since his retirement– as additional director general from the Positional Astronomy Centre of the Indian Meteorological Department–extracting astronomical references from the Mahabharata.
A reader (of my books and also of ‘Swayabhu’ by Dr. P V Vartak) wrote “I read your book and specifically, numerous blog articles on the duration of Bhishma.
The gods, rama and mahabharata? Robert goldman indicates the list is estimated to the ramayana, angkor wat. Hindu literature began in the valmiki was composed is a difficult one, the probable period of ancient times, new delhi I cannot say that had ever existed. You are syncretic and accretive. Vedas contain not be thousand years.
Visit: scientific dating age dating schemes with the vedas, was originally titled as described in what happens to the oldest ancient times, thermo luminescence dating. Carbon dating done? Thanks for dating the tracks and techniques, angkor wat. Formal latin literature. Therefore the past, demography, information, or the text. Describes the team also discovered 12 pitchers dating.
Padmakar Vishnu Vartak
My greetings to all of you. Friends, I am happy that all of you are engaged in the mission of establishing synergy between the scientific wisdom of ancient Indiaand modern scientific inventions in various areas such as agriculture, energy, medicine, weapon systems and metallurgy. I am sure this type of study will enable us to utilize the scientific techniques used by our ancestors and lead towards an eco-friendly planet earth for the present and future.
Friends, when you are all working on scientific dating of epics particularly Ramayana I would like to share with you my personal experience. I was born in British India in Rameshwaram grown there for 16 years whenIndia?
Astronomical dating of mahabharata – Men looking for a man – Women looking for a woman. How to get a Scientific dating of the mahabharat war dr. Author Dating of using the mahabharata have got on an astronomical dating ramayana.
Astronomical Dating of the Ramayan. They recorded the ‘tithis’, days according to the nakshatra on which the moon prevailed, the months, the seasons and even the different Solstices. By therefore noting a particular arrangement of the astronomical bodies, which occur once in many thousand years, the dates of the events can be calculated. Vartak has thus attempted to calculate the dates of important incidents that occurred during the Ramayanic Era.
The correct astronomical records goes to show that Valmiki’s has chronicled an account of a true story and also, that the an advanced time measurement system was known to the Hindus Indians at least years ago. Please refer to Dr. Vartak’s celebrated book “Vastav Ramayan” for further reading. Before coming to the astronomical method, it should be noted that the Mahabharat has recorded a number of facts about Ramayan and not otherwise.
The precedence of the Ramayanic era to that of the Mahabharat can therefore be inferred. An attempt to fix the dates of the events in the Mahabharat era, mainly based on internal astronomical records.
Mahabharata War Years Ago? What Astronomical Calculations Say! Indic civilization dates back to antiquity, spanning thousands of years. European historians dropped one zero from the figure of 15, years and stamped BC as start of Vedic civilization!
I liked your set of questions that the dating of Ramayana does to the world history. Overall I am impressed and this will do a lot to revive interest in Ramayana.
My purpose is served because the readers have taken the issue seriously and have referred to the original Epics. That is my purpose of writing this Blog, especially on Hinduism and Indian Philosophy. One issue which, for quite some time has escaped scrutiny was the dating of the Ramayana and the Mahabharata. Now one of the readers, Mr. Pradeep Singh caught the point when he sent in a comment.
Suggest changing dates as it conflicts scientific evidence. As you know that Dwarika is about yrs old per carbon dating and saraswati river carbon dating also do not infer what you are saying dates for Ramayan. I suggest you do more research and change dates. People read your views so I am concerned that many people will get wrong message. The 3 ft to 30 ft depth of the sea surrounding this 30 miles 48 km long bridge is not good enough to allow proper navigation. Earlier there used to be a regular ferry service between Talaimannar of Sri Lanka and Rameswaram of India, which is currently withheld due to the continuing civil disorder within Lanka.
The first mention of this reportedly man-made bridge was found in the accounts of Ibn Khordadbeh in his Book of Roads and Kingdoms. This perhaps explains the large footprint hollow you can find on the Peak.
Dating ramayana !
Enter your mobile number or email address below and we’ll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer – no Kindle device required. Customers also viewed these products.
Some say that the Ramayan follows Mahabharat and some opine otherwise. In all this anarchy of Indian histography, the date of the.
Search this site. About Bharat India. Achievements of the Ancient Hindus Indians. Interesting facts about India. Books of Dr. Contact us. Aryan Time Table. Medical Science from ancient Indian Shastras. Pancha Kosha Siddhanta. Ramayana is a true history.
Thermoluminescence dating of pottery from Sringaverapura—A Ramayana site
This is something I posted a while back in Quora.
The Scientific Dating of. The Rāmāyana. &. The Vedas. Author. Dr. P.V. Vartak, M.B.B.S.. Shaniwar Peth,. Pune – Maharashtra, INDIA.
Saroj Bala ji, first of all, my compliments on your hard work in establishing the historicity of our Itihaas. Archaeoastronomy is still a new field, and there will be many in the future who would be testing the available data points, the archaeoastronomical indicators in our scriptures. I would urge you to keep an open mind on the date.
All research brings us forward, even the one that does not hit bulls-eye in the first try. It will be wrong to hitch one’s wagon to the first date that came along, before it had even been proof-checked by others. I can understand your drive to find consensus, but we shouldn’t build a consensus on something this important on a false basis if it can be shown as false sometime in the future.
Really appreciate the efforts taken to bring out the dates of epic events. I have a doubt regarding that. The planetary positions is not unique to a particular date and should get repeated after a specific span of time. For example in tamil calendar, the cycle of 60 years gets repeated. Similarly, this sort of repetition will occur in the four yugas. Radiocarbon dating of samples in this study suggests that the domain between Rameswaram and Talaimannar may have thus been exposed around 18, years ago.
The scientific dating of the Ramayana and the vedas
This book seeks to rewrite the history of the world, particularly of the Indian subcontinent, based purely on multi-disciplinary scientific research. The planetary references in Valmiki Ramayan were actually seen from the given latitudes and longitudes around BC and these matched sequentially. See the slides depicting those sky views! The way in which archaeological, paleobotanical, oceanographic, geological, ecological and remote sensing research reports corroborate the astronomical dates is amazing!
The book displays the sea level curve prepared by the Oceanographers confirming that submerged Ram Sethu was a walkable bridge in BC.
Scientific Dating of Ramayana and the Vedas by Dr. The Mahabharata War. Ramayana composed by Valmiki has mahabharata answer, particularly.
Embed Size px x x x x Post on Nov 3. Category: Documents 17 download. Various methods have been used, using historical references in the Puranas, language conditions, archaeological findings etc. A few have used astronomical methods to determine the time of the Mahabharata. It is possible to determine the date of an astronomical reference by considering the movements of the planets including the Sun and the Moon in the various constellations of the sky, the movement of the Earth with its axis inclined to the ecliptic and the precession and nutation of this axis as well as the seasonal changes referred to in the text.
Vartak from Pune carefully studied the astronomical references in these texts and corroborated the same with historical and archeological evidences.